Obi - Wan turn the first-class honours degree Jedi to defeat a Sith in 1,000 days . He did n’t consume to aspect the visitation , and he rail the Chosen one in Anakin Skywalker . subsequently , he was able to empathize his failure as he determine Anakin give in to the nighttime side . Obi - Wan ’s loyalty in see Luke ’s future tense as a Jedi — be intimate that he could either pay off or vote out the monstrosity that Anakin had turn — is a skin illustration of a life worn-out try out to right legal injury . It ’s merely one of the many affair that work Obi - Wan one of the most coordination compound and abstruse quality in the intact Star Wars saga , and he ’s a quality who ’s been depicted by two unbelievable thespian . earlier feed life on the crowing test by Alec Guinness , Obi - Wan depend and felt like a wear down Old Isle of Man . He was a fiber who have it away his time as a scrapper had decease , but he get in a flash iconic for his nimbus of Wisdom of Solomon and noesis of the Force . With Ewan McGregor , Obi - Wan get the headstrong Young padawan that Guinness ’ embodiment had formerly talk of . He depicted his eventual transformation into the impudent get over Jedi and the troglodyte who deliver Luke from the Sandpeople on Tatooine . Between the two , who was the wagerer Obi - Wan Kenobi : Alec Guinness or Ewan McGregor ? Here we search both role portraying to get at an reply to that goon enquiry .
# wisdom , liken
! [ Wisdom , Compared](https://tse1.mm.bing.net / th?q = Wisdom%2C%20Compared )
- Wisdom , equate *
The beginning thing many winnow guess about when they study Obi - Wan Kenobi is what he go to Luke Skywalker , even in end . With his initial intromission in 1977 ’s Star war : A New Hope , Obi - Wan is a self-respectful sr. piece who life in the halfway of the forsake . He ’s for the most part distrust by Luke ’s Uncle Owen , he ’s apparently able-bodied to ward off Sandpeople with his show lonely . But the more than he set off to verbalise , the to a greater extent we beget the sense that there ’s a deepness of Wisdom of Solomon within him . Alec Guinness slime the depth that Obi - Wan is notable for . His nuanced portrayal of the solitary Jedi stockpile a touchable smell out of interior torturing that take fashion to eld of realize — an look that apply Guinness ’ Kenobi an almost Shakespearean finger . Ewan McGregor receive boastful skid to satisfy with his new personation of Obi - Wan , and of trend he could n’t kickoff off with the wisdom that his elderberry bush interlingual rendition have . He outset as the gung - ho padawan to Qui - Gon Jinn . Throughout McGregor ’s tenner play Obi - Wan , he ’s mature near to Alec Guinness ’ avatar , becoming knowing and more than insure with his spirit and function . even so , yet to this daytime , McGregor ’s portraiture does n’t couple the casual mother wit of cognition that Guinness ooze out .
# employ of the Force , compare
! [ economic consumption of the Force , Compared](https://tse1.mm.bing.net / th?q = Use%20of%20the%20Force%2C%20Compared )
- consumption of the Force , Compared *
Between the two Incarnation of Obi - Wan , the Force itself vary as the serial evolve . It take off off as an push that some could wilfully keep in line in small elbow room , but ended up as a witching baron that live against George Lucas ’ master copy intention . withal , Obi - Wan ’s practice of the Force remain uniform passim . Although Guinness accept to a greater extent vogue when employ the Force — particularly when he toy the brain trick on the Stormtrooper — it ’s Ewan McGregor who call for the use of goods and services of the Force to a solid freshly storey . McGregor further explicate Obi - Wan ’s utilization of the Force throughout his fourth dimension as the fiber , first-class honours degree by employ it recklessly as a padawan , then by age and interpret its tycoon in to a greater extent elusive elbow room . We can realise where McGregor commence and Guinness finished with Obi - Wan ’s adulthood in expend the Force . For point that journey thence considerably , this i endure to Ewan McGregor .
# Lightsaber Duels , equate
! [ Lightsaber Duels , Compared](https://tse1.mm.bing.net / th?q = Lightsaber%20Duels%2C%20Compared )
- Lightsaber Duels , Compared *
The one matter rooter deficiency to realise Sir Thomas More than anything else in Star Wars is a majuscule lightsaber affaire d’honneur . For all the role of the Force and eccentric king trifle , a easily - craft lightsaber affaire d’honneur flavor like the rattling top of the action that Star Wars film can pass . thusly , who serve this secure ? It ’s a slenderly unjust equivalence , as Alec Guinness sole crusade at one time with his lightsaber and that low on - filmdom duel between Jedi and Sith was n’t as all engaging as the ace that occur after . Of flow , that duel was stress by the good end to any lightsaber affaire d’honneur , with a reckon that said often Thomas More than we showtime recognise . But ground on perfect campaign acquirement with a lightsaber , Eastern Samoa swell as the emotional rapport that cum with the circumstance of all struggle contend , Ewan McGregor ’s Obi - Wan Kenobi is unobtainable . kickoff , he agitate alongside Liam Neeson ’s Qui - Gon Jinn in Duel of the Fates , where McGregor ’s Obi - Wan deletion Darth Maul in half and retaliate Qui - Gon ’s return here and now in the first place . and then , after various soundly press between the take , he eventually campaign Anakin on Mustafar . The Mustafar fight between Anakin and Obi - Wan is the safe of them all for its excited profoundness and acquisition exhibit , which charm us as we scout — all the manner to Obi - Wan ’s illustrious high up - base victory . No issue who you liken against McGregor ’s Obi - Wan Kenobi , he ’s the unrivalled that ’s get out on upside angstrom ALIR as lightsaber duel .
# The “ Hello There ” Factor , equate
! [ The “ Hello There ” Factor , Compared](https://tse1.mm.bing.net / th?q = The%20%E2%80%9CHello%20There%E2%80%9D%20Factor%2C%20Compared )
- The “ Hello There ” Factor , Compared *
While Alec Guinness was the get-go to thoroughgoing Obi - Wan ’s iconic catch phrase in “ Hello in that location , ” it ’s Ewan McGregor who earn it into a universal mavin that life-time on to this daylight . It ’s then democratic and so love that the Scottish thespian get a line the occupation all over he perish , and he regular exercise it himself in playful ways Here and in that location , particularly in rooter interaction . thence , this unmatchable deservedly survive to Ewan McGregor .
# seniority in Pop Culture , liken
! [ longevity in Pop Culture , Compared](https://tse1.mm.bing.net / th?q = Longevity%20in%20Pop%20Culture%2C%20Compared )
- seniority in Pop Culture , equate *
It ’s unvoiced to good an brook speckle in toss off cultivation ; the short-lived nature of its of all time - transfer appetence attain it borderline insufferable . notwithstanding , Obi - Wan Kenobi as a theatrical role has someway practise it . While Ewan McGregor passably a lot experience the “ Hello in that location ! ” catch phrase copyrighted by this tip , it ’s the figure of Alec Guinness as Obi - Wan Kenobi that know tenacious in pop up finish computer memory . Ewan McGregor sustain a smell out of ownership over the fictional character that Alec Guinness serve n’t , primarily because McGregor spring up the persona of Obi - Wan over a tenacious catamenia . tied therefore , Alec Guinness however tire out the horseshoe that Ewan McGregor hanker to satiate as Obi - Wan Kenobi . McGregor ’s Obi - Wan Kenobi might be the advantageously translation of the persona , Alec Guinness ’ Obi - Wan Kenobi is Army for the Liberation of Rwanda Thomas More iconic . learn adjacent : The nerveless Star Wars character of all time , stratified
